How to switch (or fire) your financial advisor without a tax mess
Short answer: Choose your new advisor first, then let the new firm request the transfer. Most brokerage accounts move through the Automated Customer Account Transfer Service (ACATS) under FINRA Rule 11870, which sets deadlines for firms to validate and complete transfers. Ask to move holdings “in kind” rather than selling, so you do not trigger taxes just by switching. You do not have to call the old advisor first.
Step by step
- Choose the new advisor. Use how to choose a financial advisor and questions to ask.
- Open matching accounts at the new custodian (same type and registration: individual, joint, IRA, trust).
- Sign the transfer form. The new firm submits it; under FINRA Rule 11870 the old firm must validate or take exception within set business days, then complete the transfer.
- Move in kind where possible. Some funds or products cannot transfer and may have to be sold; ask both firms which holdings those are and the tax effect before anything is sold.
- Watch for fees and timing. Ask about transfer-out fees, surrender charges on annuities, and any final advisory fee.
- Retirement accounts: move IRAs by direct trustee-to-trustee transfer rather than taking a distribution; employer plans follow the plan’s rules.
- Close the loop. Confirm everything arrived, update beneficiaries and automatic transfers, and send the old advisor a short written notice ending the advisory agreement if your contract requires it.
Get matched with a financial advisor
Answer three quick questions. We match you with advisors whose services and minimums fit.
Should you tell your advisor first?
You can, but it is not required for the transfer. A short written notice is usually enough, and you do not owe an explanation.
When to switch
- You cannot get a clear answer on what you pay in dollars
- The advisor will not confirm fiduciary status in writing
- Service has dropped or your needs have changed
- New disclosures appear on BrokerCheck or IAPD
Comparing firm types? Read independent RIA vs wirehouse vs bank and check fees with the fee calculator.
Frequently asked questions
How do I switch financial advisors?
Choose the new advisor, open matching accounts at the new custodian, and sign a transfer form the new firm submits. Ask to move holdings in kind.
How long does an ACATS transfer take?
Under FINRA Rule 11870 the old firm generally has one business day to validate the request or take exception, and must complete the transfer within three business days after validation. Exceptions and non-transferable holdings can delay it.
Will switching advisors trigger taxes?
Transferring holdings in kind generally does not. Selling holdings in a taxable account can. Ask which holdings cannot transfer before anything is sold.
Do I have to tell my old advisor I'm leaving?
Not for the transfer. Your advisory contract may require written notice to end the agreement.
Are there fees to transfer an account?
Some firms charge a transfer-out fee, and some products such as annuities can carry surrender charges. Ask both firms.
Tell us what you need and we will match you with professionals that fit. It is free, and you decide who to talk to.
Related on Sam’s List
Some professionals on Sam’s List pay for visibility or leads. Inclusion and order do not rank professionals. This page is general education, not investment, tax, or legal advice, and it does not recommend any adviser, product, or strategy. Check any professional on Investor.gov and FINRA BrokerCheck before you hire. Firm names are never shown on Get a quote matches.