7 Things to Settle Before You Sell Shares in a Tender Offer

7 Things to Settle Before You Sell Shares in a Tender Offer

The email arrives with a price, a portal link, and a deadline three weeks out. There is an FAQ attached, written by people who cannot give tax advice and will tell you so twice.

That is how most people meet employee tender offer shares: real money, a hard cutoff, and nobody in the loop whose job is your outcome. Your coworkers are guessing.

What follows is what to settle first. It is not an argument for selling and not an argument for holding. Doug Johnson CPA is a Los Angeles firm on Sam's List that works with high earners holding equity compensation, with scope and limits near the end.

1. Employee Tender Offer Shares Start From Three Different Places

The headline price is the same for everyone. What you are selling is not.

Shares you bought by exercising options are property you own, with a cost and a start date. RSU shares are also property you own, but they arrived through a different door, and the tax event that put them in your hands already happened. Unexercised options are not shares at all, and if a tender lets you participate with them you are doing two things at once, the second with consequences the first did not have.

The limitation: equity portals are frequently wrong about cost basis and acquisition dates, especially after a split or a change of administrator. Treat the portal as a starting point and reconcile it against your grant documents, which settle it.

2. The Holding Period, and the Date It Is Measured From

Whether gain on a sale is treated as short-term or long-term turns on how long you have held the shares. The part people get wrong is the start date. It is not the grant date, and usually not the vesting date. For shares acquired by exercise, the clock generally starts when you acquired the shares. For RSU shares, when they were delivered. Those are different dates from the ones most people carry in their head, and the difference can decide which side of the line you land on.

The limitation: those rules have exceptions that depend on your grant type and what you did earlier. This is the item most worth having a professional confirm, because it is not reversible once the window closes.

3. Whether the Sale Runs Through Payroll Changes the Cash You See

Some tenders pay you like a stock sale. Some run all or part of the proceeds through payroll, with withholding taken out before the money reaches you.

This is not a detail. It changes the number that lands in your account, and it changes what happens at filing time in the opposite direction. The offer documents usually say which, in one sentence buried in a section on mechanics. Find that sentence.

The limitation: withholding is not your actual liability. What is withheld can be more or less than what you end up owing, so a comfortable net deposit tells you nothing about whether a balance is coming.

4. The QSBS Question, Worth Asking Even When the Answer Is No

Qualified small business stock treatment can matter more than everything else here combined, and most people in most tenders do not qualify.

Ask anyway. The test depends on what the company was when your shares were issued, what kind of business it is, and how you acquired and held the shares. Employees assume they are out because the company is large now, which is the wrong reference point. The question is about then, not now. The rules also changed for stock issued after July 4, 2025, so shares from different issuances may not be analyzed the same way.

The limitation: this is fact-specific and not a self-service determination. Company materials usually stay silent, because the company is not making a representation about your personal treatment. A wrong assumption in either direction is expensive.

5. Employee Tender Offer Shares Get Prorated, So You May Not Sell What You Offered

Almost every company-run tender caps things: a limit per person, and a total the buyer will take.

If employees collectively offer more than that total, the offers get prorated. You tender the maximum and sell a fraction of it, usually after you have committed the money to something. Read the proration language before you build a plan around the proceeds.

The limitation: you generally will not know your allocation until after the window closes, so you spend a stretch holding an election you cannot revoke with no idea of the outcome. Check the withdrawal terms too. In a private company tender those rights are set by the offer documents rather than by a single rule that applies everywhere, so read what yours say about when you can pull an election back.

6. The Concentration Question Underneath the Tax Question

Tax treatment is the question people ask. It is usually not the biggest one.

The bigger one is what share of your net worth remains tied to one private company after this, and how that sits next to the fact that your salary comes from the same place. Work out the after-tax figure honestly and look at where it leaves you.

The limitation: concentration is a personal risk question, not a tax one, and the right answer differs enormously by person. Nothing here says a concentrated position should be reduced or maintained. If it is a large share of what you have, raise it with a qualified professional before the deadline rather than during the last weekend.

7. What the Price Tells You, and What It Does Not

A tender price is a real price a real buyer agreed to pay. That makes it more informative than a 409A valuation and less informative than a public market.

What it tells you: someone was willing to transact at that number, on those terms, on that date. What it does not: that the number is the company's value per share in any general sense. Tender prices are negotiated, they attach to a specific class of stock, and preferred shares can carry protections your common shares do not.

The limitation: comparing the tender price to the last primary round is common and misleading, because the two often describe different securities. Check what class you hold and what the tendered price applies to before treating them as one number.

Where a CPA Who Works on Equity Compensation Fits

The reason people skip professional help on a tender is the calendar. Three weeks is not long.

Doug Johnson CPA is a Los Angeles firm founded in 2024 with 3 employees, serving clients nationwide, and it positions itself for growing businesses and for high earners with equity compensation. Items 2 and 4 are where someone who has read grant documents before saves you from an assumption you cannot unwind. Doug Johnson CPA has 15 verified client reviews on Sam's List as of 2026-09-28. Each review is submitted by an individual who identifies as a client of the firm and rates it on communication, subject-matter knowledge, and overall satisfaction. Reviews reflect those individual experiences and do not represent an endorsement by Sam's List. Doug Johnson CPA is a paying Sam's List member, and payment does not buy, influence, or remove reviews. Ratings and rankings are not indicative of future performance or results.

The limitations, plainly. The firm is two years old with 3 employees, so capacity inside a compressed window is fair to ask about directly. It lists minimums of $250,000 in income or $250,000 in revenue, which puts some tender participants outside its range. And no CPA can tell you whether to sell. What one can do is price each option for you.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I have to participate in a tender offer?

No. A company-run tender is an opportunity to sell, not an obligation, and declining generally has no effect on your grants or your employment. Some people participate fully, some partially, some not at all, and all three are ordinary. The decision depends on facts this article cannot see.

Can I set money aside for taxes before I know my final allocation?

Not precisely, which is the awkward part of item 5. A common approach is to hold the proceeds until you have an actual number and a professional estimate. Anything you spend before the treatment is settled is money you may need back at filing time.

Will my company tell me the tax consequences?

Almost never, and that is deliberate rather than unhelpful. Companies describe mechanics and disclaim personal tax advice, because your treatment depends on facts they do not have, including what you did with earlier grants. Read their materials for how the tender works, then take your documents to a tax professional.

If you are inside a window right now, pull your grant documents and acquisition dates first, because most of the questions above are answered there rather than in the offer email. You can browse accountants on Sam's List who work with equity compensation.

---

About the author: Kimberly Green is the cofounder of Sam's List, where business owners and high earners find vetted CPAs, financial advisors, and fractional CFOs. She's met one-on-one with 400+ financial professionals and writes from the real data behind thousands of client-advisor matches. Ask her anything about finding an accountant - she's heard it all, including the questions people are afraid to ask.